5thtimesthecharm
Well-Known Member
Hello all,
I hate for my first post to be like this, but here we go. I'll start off with a little background.
I don't work in winter, no heated garage haha.
I got this big betsy 89 fifth ave for the low low price of $1500 3 maybe 4 years ago now.
To be clear, it is in my name HOWEVER it IS NOT ON THE ROAD, so I cannot test drive it any further than my drive way. I have driven it down the road to a local business (maybe 200 meters away) and turned around there. But I cannot do a highway drive or anything. I apologize as I know that will make any testing or diagnosis difficult.
Has roughly 630000 on the dial but let's be real it's probably been rolled over.
It was stored outside in the home of the squirrels for roughly 15 years.
My first year with it, was spent removing all inoperable and broken parts in the engine bay that I could find-
Smog pump and bracket gone
Charcoal canister gone
Alternator replaced
AC removed, replaced with pulley from a non ac 318
Voltage regulator replaced
Belts replaced
Air filter and spark plugs new
New battery
Oil/filter change
This led to the entire fuel system being redone
Dropped the tank, rusted to the point of falling apart at a glance, and a hole in the trunk I suppose from the evaporating gas
So hole patched then,
New tank
New sending unit
New lines ran
New filter
Only to realize the ignition didn't work(something wrong with key tumblers)so had to replace that as well.
Now last year unfortunately I was working a lot, and this car being stored at my father's means I only get a day a week if that to work on it, so I did not get far.
However brake lines ran and replaced
Calipers
Front and rear pads and hardware all replaced
All 4 tires replaced
This year however, this year I had time. And so
I started it, and drove it out of the garage. It ran like crap, but what do you expect after sitting that long so with it outside, started working again.
Front and rear shocks replaced(monroes)
New wires(Taylor's)
New cap(standard)
New rotor(standard)
Vac lines replaced
Carb rebuilt twice(Holley 6280)
New coil (bluestreak)
Old inoperable radio that wasn't original or even wired properly removed and replaced with a pioneer I had laying around
Those side lights in the rear doors, replaced with LEDs.
All fuses and flasher replaced
Fuel gauge wasn't working, fixed that
EGR valve cleaned
Rad hoses all replaced
Old coolant all flushed out, but have to still cycle to get the new stuff in.
I should also mention that the metal line going down to the 3rd cat was rotted off of both ends, and I had no idea where it was meant to go, besides the cat of course. So I just pulled it and tossed it. The cat leaks exhaust from the hole it left but I have a pipe to replace that cat.
The metal line for the air pump however is still fully intact, not capped off, just sitting in the engine bay.
So to sum up, all primary fuel delivery, ignition, electrical and spark components have been replaced entirely, and tested good.
And they replaced ALL ORIGINAL PARTS, Mopar wires, rotor, coil ect all original, honestly amazed lol
Carb was dunked and rebuilt the first time, then I tore it apart again to double check everything when car ran terrible afterwards, but all is in spec.
It is the Holley 6280 feedback model
Cyl compression all around is good
All rubber vac lines replaced, at least all the ones I can see or all the ones I felt could cause issues.
Oh and all unused ports on the carb EXCEPT the bowl vent have been blocked off.
The only thing I have been unable to check is timing and vacuum, I don't have the tools. But I'll be buying both a timing light and vac gauge next pay.
Now here is the problem, even after everything that had been done, it still runs like crap. If it runs.
To be fair, it does start up and run a lot better than when it was first started mind you.
Not sure where to start with this but here goes.
So on a fully cold, sat overnight start.
It will start and run like an absolute champ, high idle seems to be fine, maybe a little high but no problems for the minute or two it takes to drop off high idle.
Once it does, it will seem to idle fine, might have a small hiccup here and there but honestly I've been blaming those tiny hiccups on how long it sat before I got my grubby hands on her. But again all seems fine.
But then 30 seconds to a minute later, it acts as if it drops off high idle again, and rpms go even lower.
This is the point where it starts to shudder, shake and act like it's going to stall and it probably will stall unless you give it a shot.
If I give it a shot it will come back no problem, but continues to idle at that very low rpm. These cars don't have a tach so I can't say for sure how low.
I bought a tach gauge to determine that but havnt had a chance to install yet. If I had to guess, I would say it's idling around 600rpm maybe even lower "scary" though 630rpm is what it's supposed to be at?
I also noticed there is a...idk winding sound? At that low rpm mark. I'm not sure what to call it but I only hear it once it drops low. Sounds like maybe coil wine.
Oh and when it is at high idle or that mid idle, the voltage gauge seems fine, once it drops to that low idle state the gauge starts fluctuating. Gauge doesn't have numbers of course but if I had to guess it goes up and down 1-2 volts. Give it a shot of gas and the gauge stabalizes for a few seconds till it drops back down to that low idle.
Now, if you drop it in gear it does not stall, it shudders a small amount but stays running. All gears act roughly the same.
R and D back and fourth in the driveway it surges a small amount both ways as soon as it is fed any gas.
Took it for a very short drive, 200 meters or less both ways.
The entire time it was surging/lacking power it did not stall however, and that was with my mechanic friend and other friend in the car, so it was pushing about 800 pounds with the 3 of us.
I tried pulling the green pin of the feedback solenoid out, and car acts no different with or without that connected.
I'm a driveway mechanic, I've done a lot. Never gone as far as rebuilding an engine yet. Valve cover replacement at best. But I'm at my wits end. Mostly just frustrated at this point lol
Mechanic friend is not familiar with the fuel control computer system, so he is saying that might very well be the problem. He is a cheby/GMC/Pontiac guy(owns a 76 trans am that he fully rebuilt)
His timing light got ran over, only reason we haven't checked that yet.
I think it's the feedback solenoid not reading right so the computer isn't giving it the fuel it needs, or the computer just not giving the fuel it needs in general.
If we spray intake clean while it's running like crap it does rev a little higher but then settles right back down.
Belts are tight, and I hear no obvious vac leak screaming sound lol
Again sorry for this being so long, hopefully some have some ideas of areas to check lol
I've also most definitely forgotten some stuff we have tried, I'll let yas know if they come up
Cheers
I hate for my first post to be like this, but here we go. I'll start off with a little background.
I don't work in winter, no heated garage haha.
I got this big betsy 89 fifth ave for the low low price of $1500 3 maybe 4 years ago now.
To be clear, it is in my name HOWEVER it IS NOT ON THE ROAD, so I cannot test drive it any further than my drive way. I have driven it down the road to a local business (maybe 200 meters away) and turned around there. But I cannot do a highway drive or anything. I apologize as I know that will make any testing or diagnosis difficult.
Has roughly 630000 on the dial but let's be real it's probably been rolled over.
It was stored outside in the home of the squirrels for roughly 15 years.
My first year with it, was spent removing all inoperable and broken parts in the engine bay that I could find-
Smog pump and bracket gone
Charcoal canister gone
Alternator replaced
AC removed, replaced with pulley from a non ac 318
Voltage regulator replaced
Belts replaced
Air filter and spark plugs new
New battery
Oil/filter change
This led to the entire fuel system being redone
Dropped the tank, rusted to the point of falling apart at a glance, and a hole in the trunk I suppose from the evaporating gas
So hole patched then,
New tank
New sending unit
New lines ran
New filter
Only to realize the ignition didn't work(something wrong with key tumblers)so had to replace that as well.
Now last year unfortunately I was working a lot, and this car being stored at my father's means I only get a day a week if that to work on it, so I did not get far.
However brake lines ran and replaced
Calipers
Front and rear pads and hardware all replaced
All 4 tires replaced
This year however, this year I had time. And so
I started it, and drove it out of the garage. It ran like crap, but what do you expect after sitting that long so with it outside, started working again.
Front and rear shocks replaced(monroes)
New wires(Taylor's)
New cap(standard)
New rotor(standard)
Vac lines replaced
Carb rebuilt twice(Holley 6280)
New coil (bluestreak)
Old inoperable radio that wasn't original or even wired properly removed and replaced with a pioneer I had laying around
Those side lights in the rear doors, replaced with LEDs.
All fuses and flasher replaced
Fuel gauge wasn't working, fixed that
EGR valve cleaned
Rad hoses all replaced
Old coolant all flushed out, but have to still cycle to get the new stuff in.
I should also mention that the metal line going down to the 3rd cat was rotted off of both ends, and I had no idea where it was meant to go, besides the cat of course. So I just pulled it and tossed it. The cat leaks exhaust from the hole it left but I have a pipe to replace that cat.
The metal line for the air pump however is still fully intact, not capped off, just sitting in the engine bay.
So to sum up, all primary fuel delivery, ignition, electrical and spark components have been replaced entirely, and tested good.
And they replaced ALL ORIGINAL PARTS, Mopar wires, rotor, coil ect all original, honestly amazed lol
Carb was dunked and rebuilt the first time, then I tore it apart again to double check everything when car ran terrible afterwards, but all is in spec.
It is the Holley 6280 feedback model
Cyl compression all around is good
All rubber vac lines replaced, at least all the ones I can see or all the ones I felt could cause issues.
Oh and all unused ports on the carb EXCEPT the bowl vent have been blocked off.
The only thing I have been unable to check is timing and vacuum, I don't have the tools. But I'll be buying both a timing light and vac gauge next pay.
Now here is the problem, even after everything that had been done, it still runs like crap. If it runs.
To be fair, it does start up and run a lot better than when it was first started mind you.
Not sure where to start with this but here goes.
So on a fully cold, sat overnight start.
It will start and run like an absolute champ, high idle seems to be fine, maybe a little high but no problems for the minute or two it takes to drop off high idle.
Once it does, it will seem to idle fine, might have a small hiccup here and there but honestly I've been blaming those tiny hiccups on how long it sat before I got my grubby hands on her. But again all seems fine.
But then 30 seconds to a minute later, it acts as if it drops off high idle again, and rpms go even lower.
This is the point where it starts to shudder, shake and act like it's going to stall and it probably will stall unless you give it a shot.
If I give it a shot it will come back no problem, but continues to idle at that very low rpm. These cars don't have a tach so I can't say for sure how low.
I bought a tach gauge to determine that but havnt had a chance to install yet. If I had to guess, I would say it's idling around 600rpm maybe even lower "scary" though 630rpm is what it's supposed to be at?
I also noticed there is a...idk winding sound? At that low rpm mark. I'm not sure what to call it but I only hear it once it drops low. Sounds like maybe coil wine.
Oh and when it is at high idle or that mid idle, the voltage gauge seems fine, once it drops to that low idle state the gauge starts fluctuating. Gauge doesn't have numbers of course but if I had to guess it goes up and down 1-2 volts. Give it a shot of gas and the gauge stabalizes for a few seconds till it drops back down to that low idle.
Now, if you drop it in gear it does not stall, it shudders a small amount but stays running. All gears act roughly the same.
R and D back and fourth in the driveway it surges a small amount both ways as soon as it is fed any gas.
Took it for a very short drive, 200 meters or less both ways.
The entire time it was surging/lacking power it did not stall however, and that was with my mechanic friend and other friend in the car, so it was pushing about 800 pounds with the 3 of us.
I tried pulling the green pin of the feedback solenoid out, and car acts no different with or without that connected.
I'm a driveway mechanic, I've done a lot. Never gone as far as rebuilding an engine yet. Valve cover replacement at best. But I'm at my wits end. Mostly just frustrated at this point lol
Mechanic friend is not familiar with the fuel control computer system, so he is saying that might very well be the problem. He is a cheby/GMC/Pontiac guy(owns a 76 trans am that he fully rebuilt)
His timing light got ran over, only reason we haven't checked that yet.
I think it's the feedback solenoid not reading right so the computer isn't giving it the fuel it needs, or the computer just not giving the fuel it needs in general.
If we spray intake clean while it's running like crap it does rev a little higher but then settles right back down.
Belts are tight, and I hear no obvious vac leak screaming sound lol
Again sorry for this being so long, hopefully some have some ideas of areas to check lol
I've also most definitely forgotten some stuff we have tried, I'll let yas know if they come up
Cheers
Last edited: