The velour in a 5th Ave is probably a little stronger material than the corded fabric in your Cordoba. I'm not sure that I've ever seen a ripped velour seat from a 5th Ave. The fabric in your car does that, the corded material splits apart like that after years of exposure.
The leather is, as I mentioned, a very healthy, thick hide. I have one tear in my drivers seat that I will repair. Leather is fairly repairable, I glue in a piece of vinyl on the back side of the leather to give it structure, cut out another piece of leather to fill in any missing bits, and then I smear over it a flexible leather 'bondo' that Leatherique sells. Redye it and you'd be hard pressed to see a repair had been made. As well, leather is maintainable. Keep it treated, keep it covered in dye and it will last scores of years.And its leather, it has its own tactile reward.
Life would be boring without decisions to make.